skip to main content

Workers’ Compensation Program Turnaround: Case Study

How a National Property Maintenance Company Achieved a 60% Reduction in Open Claims

August 03, 2026
Close-up of engineer shaking hands with mature worker indoors in metal workshop.

Overview

A large, multi-state maintenance services organization partnered with our team to stabilize and transform its workers’ compensation program during a period of internal transition. Within three years, we delivered measurable financial improvements, stronger claim oversight and a smooth migration into a new insurance and TPA structure.

The Challenge

The company was facing escalating claim costs and operational inconsistency, including:

•    Rising open claim counts and financial exposure.
•    Limited adjuster engagement and inconsistent action plans.
•    Inefficient vendor agreements slowing claim resolution.
•    High outstanding reserves impacting collateral negotiations.
•    A pending transition into a new self-insured program requiring coordination.

They needed a partner capable of both strategic program guidance and tactical claims intervention.

Our Solution

We implemented a structured, high-touch workers’ compensation management model designed for high-frequency industries like janitorial and maintenance:

Program Stabilization

  • Rapid assessment of workflows and vendor agreements.
  • Immediate process improvements to accelerate claim handling.
  • Launch of multi-phase claim closure initiatives with the insurer.

Ongoing Proactive Oversight

  • Continuous adjuster engagement to drive timely action.
  • File audits for reserve accuracy, closure opportunities and action plan quality.
  • Litigation strategy and defense counsel oversight.
  • Monthly stewardship meetings with leadership.
  • Participation in insurer-led claim reviews.
  • Use of analytics to identify trends and course correct.

The Results

A three-year transformation delivered measurable financial impact.

Metric

Before

After

Improvement

Open Claims

76

30

-60%

Total Incurred

$4.54M

$2.73M

-40%

Outstanding

$1.70M

$0.68M

-60%

Reserves

Total Paid

$2.83M

$2.05M

-28%

Overall Result

A sharper, leaner, data-driven workers’ compensation program that improved financial leverage and lowered long-term cost of risk.

Supporting the Next Phase

As the organization transitioned into a national self-insured program administered by a new TPA, we provided:

  • Seamless handoff planning for remaining insurer-handled claims.
  • Alignment of triage, investigation, and escalation protocols.
  • Recommendations for improved post-transition claims management.
  • Consistent oversight to prevent claim creep during program change.

Why Clients in Cleaning and Maintenance Choose Us

  • Proven impact in high-frequency, multi-location industries.
  • Hands-on, proactive claims oversight that drives real cost reduction.
  • Strategic guidance through complex program transitions.
  • A partnership model that strengthens both operations and financial outcomes.

Contact us today to discover how we can help you reduce claim costs, improve adjuster performance and build long-term program stability.

https://www.alteritygroup.com/insights/workers-compensation-case-study/
2026 Copyright | All Right Reserved